Baltic Synergia Consulting
Management

Inventory management when steel prices jump 12% in a week

By Ewa Borkowska, Risk Specialist·September 15, 2024·7 min read

Steel in a factory is not just raw material lying in the yard; it is primarily frozen cash that can burn the margin worked for over 7 months during sudden price spikes. At Baltic Synergia Consulting, we regularly see how a failure to decide to buy on Monday morning turns into 48,000 PLN of loss by Friday afternoon.

When the price on the invoice stops making sense

Last Tuesday, one of our clients from Pomerania received a new offer for S355 steel. The price was exactly 13% higher compared to an order from eight days ago, which at their production scale meant an additional 32,400 PLN cost on one transport. This situation is not an anomaly; it is a new reality where old price lists can be thrown in the bin after 72 hours. If your purchasing department waits for a 'better moment' and wholesalers in Gdynia or Elbląg shorten the validity of offers to one day, it's a signal that control over the budget is slipping away.

The problem lies not in the price of steel itself, but in the fact that most factories still calculate production costs based on average prices from the last quarter. We look for holes in everything and usually find them in spreadsheets that do not account for market dynamics. When steel goes up by 12% in a week, your finished product selling price, set 3 months ago, stops even covering the shop's fixed costs. Numbers must add up, and if you don't update them weekly, you're simply paying for the privilege of working.

We saw a case where a small production hall employing 24 people lost all financial liquidity because the owner believed a supplier's assurances that 'prices will drop soon'. They didn't drop, and the company was left with an empty warehouse and contracts it couldn't fulfill without taking an expensive working capital loan at 14% annually. This is a classic example where the lack of a risk audit at an early stage led to a critical situation in less than 19 business days.

A failure to decide to buy on Monday morning is often 48,000 PLN of loss by Friday.
When the price on the invoice stops making sense

Frozen capital in an Excel sheet

At Baltic Synergia Consulting, we always repeat: we know every screw in the budget, and those screws can be very expensive when they lie idle. Holding excessive inventory when prices are rising seems smart, but only until you lack 115,000 PLN for the crew's payroll because cash is 'standing' on shelves in the form of sheets. The key is finding the balance point between production safety and liquidity, which for the average production company means a reserve for at most 14-17 days of work.

Analyzing data from 43 audits we conducted last year, we noticed a recurring error: accounting departments treat inventory as assets but rarely calculate the real cost of their storage and the risk of loss of value. If you buy steel at a peak price and the market suddenly slows down by 6%, you are left with a product no one will buy for a price covering your investment. Concrete instead of theory: check your inventory turnover ratio today before 4 PM, because that is probably where your money is escaping.

Remember that banks look at your warehouses less and less favorably. At current interest rates, financing inventory with a loan is a sport for the brave or the unaware. In one plant in Tczew, we managed to free up 87,600 PLN of cash in just 3 weeks simply by changing the delivery schedule and giving up on stocking raw material 'just in case'. This money immediately went toward paying off the most burdensome liabilities, which saved their credit scoring.

How to talk to suppliers so as not to be played

Raw material suppliers have one goal: to sell high and secure their own risk at your expense. If you hear that 'everyone is raising prices' and 'there's no room for negotiation', you probably don't have hard data in hand. During our consultations, we teach company owners how to use exchange indices and audit data to beat down intermediaries' margins by 2-4%. This might seem like little, but with a turnover of around 500,000 PLN, that's an extra 15,000 that stays in your pocket.

It's also worth considering diversification. Relying on one supplier from Gdańsk just because 'we've known each other for 8 years' is a direct path to overpaying. We recommend having at least 3 proven sources, of which one should be outside your immediate region. Our analyses show that companies with three suppliers pay on average 7% less per ton of steel than those that are 'loyal' to one wholesaler who doesn't have scruples when it comes to hikes.

Heads-up: Always check the weight of delivered material on your own weighbridge. We happened to detect a billing error at a level of 2.3% of total mass with one of the big players on the market. At 40 tons per month, that's almost a ton of steel you pay for but never saw on the floor. Such small differences build your loss, which isn't visible in the daily rush but hits you in the face during the annual summary.

Loyalty to one supplier costs an average of 7% margin on each ton of raw material.
How to talk to suppliers so as not to be played

An early warning system in your company

You don't need an expensive ERP system for 200,000 PLN to keep your finger on the pulse. At Baltic Synergia Consulting, we implement simple control mechanisms that take an employee 12 minutes a day and give a full picture of the situation. It's about tracking three key numbers: the purchase price of the last batch, the current market price, and the level of cash on the operating account. If these parameters start to diverge, the system must 'scream' and block new quotes for clients until the cost estimates are updated.

Most liquidity problems start with a reaction time that is too long. If raw material prices jump on Monday and your salespeople are still sending offers with Friday's prices, each sold product brings you closer to bankruptcy. At one of our clients, we introduced a rule: every offer above 15,400 PLN must be confirmed with the purchasing department on the day of sending. This eliminated situations in which the company lost on orders 'from the start', which previously happened on average 4 times a month.

We look for holes in everything, including production processes. Sometimes the solution for rising steel prices is not buying cheaper, but wasting less. Implementing a simple waste audit allowed a certain plant to reduce raw material consumption by 8.4%. This is like buying steel almost a tenth cheaper without a single minute of negotiation with a supplier. This is the concrete instead of theory that realy affects a factory's financial result.